Good Idea?? What do you think... The doors at Eddy Street Commons now lock at midnight. This fall the property manager set a hard close for every business on the block, and the same few weeks brought two new restaurants whose posted hours mostly end well before it. Taken with the year's other tenant changes, these moves point the same way. The block next to Notre Dame is turning into a place built around dinner. Late-night hours are becoming a smaller part of what it offers.
How the block changed in 2026
The new rule makes more sense once you see the order of the tenant changes. Over nine months, a retail store and a pizza place gave way to sit-down dinner and counter-service meals, and a new Mediterranean spot moved in near O'Rourke's.
- January 22. Urban Outfitters closed its Eddy Street store after 14 years, and Kite Realty told WNDU that a restaurant would take the space.
- February. The Observer reported that the old Blaze Pizza space was being rebuilt for BIBIBOP and that CAVA was planned for a space near O'Rourke's Public House.
- Late February. WNDU named the restaurant coming to the old Urban Outfitters space. It is Osteria Amici, an Italian restaurant from Navarre Hospitality Group that WNDU later described as Northern Italian.
- March 26. BIBIBOP held its grand opening across from Jimmy John's.
- By September 24. The midnight closing requirement was in effect for every business on the block.
- October 4. CAVA opened at 1251 N. Eddy St.
- Later in October. Osteria Amici is expected to open, and the date is not yet confirmed.
BIBIBOP took the old pizza counter, and Osteria Amici is about to fill the old clothing store. CAVA opened in its space near O'Rourke's on October 4. All three are restaurants that do most of their business around lunch and dinner.
The new hours fit inside the new rule
Lay the posted hours next to the midnight close and the pattern is plain to see.
Spot | What it is | Posted hours |
|---|---|---|
CAVA, 1251 N. Eddy St. | Mediterranean bowls and pitas | 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily |
Osteria Amici, 1145 N. Eddy St. | Northern Italian, open kitchen, two bars | Mon–Thu 4 to 10 p.m., Fri–Sat 4 to 11 p.m., Sun 4 to 9 p.m., per OpenTable |
Every Eddy Street business | Required close | Patrons out and doors locked by midnight |
CAVA's own location page shows 10:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. every day. That's a half hour later in the morning than the 10 a.m. start WNDU gave in its preview, so the restaurant's page is the one to trust. The Eddy Street location is the second one nearby. Alex Gomez, CAVA's area leader, told WNDU the company opened its first one in Mishawaka a few months earlier. The menu works the way CAVA's other locations do. You build a bowl or pita from Mediterranean ingredients, and Gomez put the number of possible combinations at over a billion.
Osteria Amici's hours aren't settled yet. On October 2, WNDU reported weekday hours of 4 to 10 p.m. and a midnight close on weekends. Its OpenTable page lists an 11 p.m. close on Friday and Saturday and a 9 p.m. close on Sunday. Either way, the kitchen is set up for dinner. Navarre has described the space as having an open kitchen, two bars, private dining rooms, and a wine and cocktail list, along with what it calls world-champion pizza. The restaurant's own site still said "Coming Soon" as of this week. On October 2, Matthew Soutra, Navarre's vice president, told WNDU the opening was about a week and a half away. OpenTable has shown reservations starting October 14. The company's first Osteria Amici is in Elkhart, and Soutra said the response there has been great.
Both new restaurants were planned months before the midnight rule existed. CAVA closes at 10 every night, and Osteria Amici's latest published close is midnight on weekends, which is exactly where the rule sets the limit. The rule cuts an hour or two from businesses that used to run late. It barely touches the newest arrivals.
What the midnight rule moved
The rule falls hardest on the places that used to run past midnight. WNDU named four: O'Rourke's Public House, Brothers Bar & Grill, Five Guys and Dave's Hot Chicken. Kite Realty manages the property. According to The Observer, Kite and local officials are using the rule to curb late-night crowds and improve public safety. None of the coverage says whether the rule is a trial or permanent.
O'Rourke's has made the most visible change. Its trivia and karaoke nights now have to wrap up much earlier so the doors are locked by midnight. The pub's general manager told The Observer that safety comes before lost sales. She said the change is "a little bit of an adjustment, but it's something that we're willing to do to make sure we can make Eddy Street Commons the safest it can be." She also described an August 12 meeting where Kite invited all the businesses, with the police chief there, to talk through safety ideas.
The incoming tenants took the news in stride. "We totally understand where the landlord and everyone's coming from," Soutra told WNDU, "that ultimately public safety is the top priority." Gomez said CAVA had met with community leaders and felt reassured. WNDU also reported that residents' views on the new hours are mixed.
For anyone who lives nearby, the practical effect is a shorter evening that starts earlier. The block now runs from lunch at CAVA to a hard stop at midnight. The newest tenants are built for the stretch between 4 and 10 p.m.
Planning an Eddy Street evening this month
With CAVA open and Osteria Amici close behind, an Eddy Street night out this October looks something like this:
- Quick dinner, any day. CAVA runs until 10 p.m. seven days a week, and BIBIBOP has been open across from Jimmy John's since March.
- Sit-down Italian, once it opens. Osteria Amici's kitchen opens at 4 p.m. If you plan to book, check its OpenTable page for the current weekend closing time, since the two published versions don't match.
- Trivia or karaoke at O'Rourke's. Expect an earlier finish than before September. The pub's events now have to end in time for midnight lockup.
- Anything after dinner. Midnight is the hard stop for every business on Eddy Street, bars included.
There's one more name to watch. In February, The Observer reported that Tous Les Jours, a bakery, was opening near Dave's Hot Chicken. NOW OPEN !!!! It would be a daytime business, which fits how the rest of the block is changing. So delicious!!
Restaurant openings and tighter hours like these shape how a block feels from one season to the next, and buyers ask about that when they look at homes near Notre Dame. If you own near Eddy Street and want to know what your home is worth this fall, Traci Gaddis can put together a free home valuation using current local sales and an honest read on the area around you. And let's grab a treat!